Symptoms and Diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorders

Parents of a child with GID
Andy Snow/Time Life Pictures/
Getty Images

Sherry and Paul Lipscomb's six-year-old son has expressed female traits since age two.
Because gender identity disorder is currently considered a psychological disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV), a mental health professional such as a psychiatrist, psychologist or therapist must make the diagnosis.

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), formerly known as the Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association, maintains and publishes the Standards of Care (SOC) -- guidelines for how to treat people with gender identity disorder. The Standards of Care are intended for professionals, individuals with gender identity disorder and their families, as well as institutions or anyone else seeking to understand current information about the psychological, medical and surgical treatments for GID.

In accordance with the Standards of Care, when an individual begins to question and feel persistent dissatisfaction with his or her gender identity, no matter at what age, therapy -- psychological, endocrine or surgical -- should begin. Treatment is intended to help the patient's well-being, not to sway or convince a person from his or her path.

Intersex Conditions

Sometimes a baby is born with a physical condition that makes it difficult to determine if the child is male or female.

According to the American Psychological Association, the current recommended terminology for intersex conditions is Disorders of Sex Development (DSD).

There are numerous conditions that fall under DSD, including abnormalities affecting external genitals, internal reproductive organs, hormones or chromosomes. Some examples of DSD conditions are:

  • Vaginal agenesis (when females are born without a vagina)
  • Penile agenesis (when males are born without a penis)
  • Partial or complete androgen insensitivity
  • Klinefelter syndrome (when males are born with an extra X chromosome)
  • Turner syndrome (when females are born with one rather than two X chromosomes)

About 1 in 1,500 babies are born with ambiguous genitalia, and many more born with other conditions that may be so subtle they aren't noticed until adulthood [source: APA Online]. Parents and doctors work together to decide on treatment, depending on the DSD condition. Sometimes surgery is offered to correct the genitals, but it's hotly debated as to when and if these surgeries should be performed.­­

Gender identity struggles may begin as early as age two to four years, when children begin to exhibit interest in cross-gender activities.

Most will outgrow symptoms of gender identity disorder before adolescence. By late adolescence or adulthood, about three quarters of boys with symptoms of gender identity disorder report homosexual or bisexual orientations. Most of the remaining 25 percent live as heterosexuals [source: Merck]. A small percentage of adolescents and adults will go on to identify as transsexuals.

Adult gender identity disorder typically manifests in late adolescence or in early to mid-adulthood, although there is no determinant age of onset. Adolescents questioning their gender identity usually report cross-gendered feelings since childhood. Later onset gender identity disorder usually appears gradually, with individuals seeking therapy in early to mid-adulthood.

Next we'll talk about the specifics -- what are the symptoms and criteria for diagnosis?