With more than 100,000 U.S. children waiting to be adopted, why do so many Americans adopt overseas? And what part does race play in their decisions?
Researchers from the University of Vermont (UVM) discovered that although many white adoptive parents were open to adopting children of other races, they drew the line at adopting African-American children.
The United States leads the world in international adoptions. The National Center for Adoption reports that Americans completed 6,441 intercountry adoptions in 2014. (This is way down, though, from the peak of 22,000 international adoptions in 2004.)
Meanwhile, there are about 108,000 children available for adoption in the U.S. as of July 2015, according to the National Council of Adoption. African-American children are overrepresented — they make up about 24 percent of the children waiting for adoption. (The African-American population in the U.S. is 13 percent).
Researchers at UVM interviewed 41 parents from the northeastern U.S. (all were white except one Asian) who had adopted 52 kids. Thirty-three of the children adopted came from other countries, mostly China, Korea and Guatemala. The researchers shared their findings in a report titled, "We Didn't Even Think About Adopting Domestically: The Role of Race and Other Factors in Shaping Parents' Decisions to Adopt Abroad." The main reasons the subjects chose to adopt kids from overseas were:
- Fear of birth parents changing their mind and wanting their child back
- Concern about open adoptions where birth parents maintain some contact with their child
- An assumption that adoptive children in the U.S. have more health issues due to alcohol or drug abuse by their mothers
Here's where it gets really interesting. While many of the parents surveyed said they were open to adopting children of any race — and even actively sought nonwhite children overseas — several drew a line in the sand when it came to black American children. In fact, 18 of the parents explicitly said they wouldn't adopt a black child. African-American children, in particular, were seen as "too different" physically and culturally.
Just two of the adopted children in the study group were African-American. The other four black children adopted came from other countries: Haiti, Tanzania and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Nikki Khanna is a sociology professor who led the study. She notes via email that U.S. adoptions from Africa have more than tripled between 2003 and 2010. But she says it's not clear why the parents she interviewed found African children more adoptable than black American kids. "For these parents, it is possible that they perceive African-American culture as more ambiguous and less defined than that of Tanzanian or Congolese culture, for example, and hence more accessible to them. More research, however, is needed."
And then, there's the race issue. Khanna says many parents cited long-standing, contentious race relations between blacks and whites as a deterrent to adopting African-American kids. "They were hesitant to enter into a situation in which they themselves had to take up and address this history with their own African-American children. Perhaps some parents feel that if they adopt from Africa that they or their African children are somehow exempt from this history. I would argue, however, that that view is ill-conceived and highly problematic."
So, what can be done to reverse negative perceptions about adopting African-American kids? Khanna says trying to convince white parents to adopt these children, despite their reservations, isn't the right approach. She advocates more education about the adoption process in the U.S., in general. "Some parents [in the study] were put off by the rules and regulations surrounding adoption in the United States, and others simply felt ill-informed about the process of domestic adoption."
She adds that there should be a more open dialogue about transracial adoption, specifically as it relates to white parents adopting African-American children. "Prospective adoptive parents need to understand the positives and negatives of transracial adoption – and perhaps, more knowledge may demystify the process and encourage more parents to adopt across racial lines."