Which works best: roll-on, stick or spray deodorant?

spray-on deodorant
One contender in the battle against sweat -- and stink. View more men's health pictures.

Deodorant use has been traced back to the ancient Sumerians, who also developed the world's first written language -- and the wheel [source: Patrick]. The first modern, mass-produced deodorant, a cream applied by hand to the underarms, started improving social lives in 1888.

By the 1950s, Americans were using roll-on deodorant (with an applicator similar to that of a ballpoint pen), and hand-dabbing our pits with cream was quickly becoming a thing of the past. Aerosol-spray deodorants followed about 10 years later, and stick deodorants came along in the 1970s, mixing deodorant with waxes, fats and emollients to form a solid bar packaged in a plastic, hand-held container.


Unfortunately, the chemical propellants once commonly used in aerosol deodorants -- chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) -- released chlorine into the atmosphere that destroyed ozone, which helps protect us from the sun's ultraviolet radiation. As of 1994, use of CFCs in aerosol sprays has been banned (though the atmosphere won't recover from our use of CFCs until 2050 or so) [source: EPA]. Manufacturers now use safer, alternate propellants.

So which is better -- roll-on, spray-on or stick deodorants? It really depends on personal preference. Spray deodorants tend to dry quicker under the arm than other deodorants. After spraying each pit for a couple seconds, you can generally flap your wings a few times and you're good to go. After using a roll-on or stick, however, you better use caution to prevent armpit-shirt contact when putting on that black T-shirt, or else you're going to be sporting white tiger stripes on it.

On the other hand, nobody likes to stand next to someone who's spraying deodorant all over the place. And people using spray deodorant aren't too thrilled when they take a deep breath of aerosol spray.

In an age of heightened airport security, gel and spray deodorants must be small in size (less than 3.4 ounces) and sealed in quart-sized baggies. Sounds like a pain when you can bring along a stick deodorant of any size you want, sans bag [source: TSA]. Land-tethered humans will just have to try all three types of deodorant to see what they like best, but for those staying dry in the sky, stick is the way to fly.


Stick or Spray Deodorant FAQ

What is the best deodorant for odor control?
The thing is, sweat is actually odorless. It's when it mixes with bacteria (from diet, medical conditions, lifestyle habits, etc.) that you get a little stinky. That means that just because a particular brand and formula worked for your friend, doesn't mean it'll work for you. You may have to try a few deodorants before you find one that has active ingredients that work for you.
Is spray deodorant bad for you?
Aerosol deodorants used to use chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) as a propellant, however those were banned in 1994. Modern spray deodorants may cause headaches if you inhale the spray during application. However, generally they're safe for most people in good health to use.
Which type of deodorant is best?
Deodorant formats are really a matter of personal preference. Spray deodorants tend to dry quicker under the arm than other deodorants, but you often end up breathing them in upon application. Some stick deodorants may leave stains on your clothes, but are easier to apply and often more cost-effective.
What is the difference between antiperspirant and deodorant?
The two work in different ways to reduce body odor, with different active ingredients. While antiperspirants work by reducing sweat, deodorants work by increasing skin’s acidity to make it less attractive to bacteria. Antiperspirants are available in over-the-counter options as well as prescription, both generally using aluminum-based compounds to block sweat pores.
Is antiperspirant bad for you?
Antiperspirant uses aluminum to block pores and reduce sweat. However, for females, there’s some concern - though no conclusive proof yet - that this ingredient may affect the estrogen receptors of breast cells, increasing a woman's chance of getting breast cancer.

Lots More Information

Related Articles


  • Environmental Protection Agency. "Ozone Layer Protection." Aug. 19, 2010. (Sept. 22, 2010)http://www.epa.gov/Ozone/geninfo/benefits.html
  • Environmental Protection Agency. "Questions and Answers on Alternative Aerosols." Aug. 19, 2010. (Sept. 22, 2010)http://www.epa.gov/Ozone/snap/aerosol/qa.html
  • Fontanez, Stefanie. "Body Odor Through the Ages: A Brief History of Deodorant." Mental Floss. Feb. 21, 2008. (Sept. 22, 2010)http://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/12530
  • Laden, Karl. Antiperspirants and deodorants. CRC Press, 1999. 0824717465, 9780824717469.http://books.google.com/books?id=WOoUoiW8FpkC&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false
  • Patrick, Bethanne Kelly; Petroski, Henry; Thompson, John. An Uncommon History of Common Things. National Geographic Books, 2009. ISBN 1426204205, 9781426204203.http://books.google.com/books?id=bcaXzXPP8ooC&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false
  • The Ozone Hole. (Sept. 22, 2010)http://www.theozonehole.com/cfc.htm
  • The Personal Care Products Council. "Antiperspirants and Deodorants." (Sept. 22, 2010) http://www.cosmeticsinfo.org/HBI/14
  • Transportation Security Administration. "Gel, Aerosol, and Stick Deodorant: Which can I take in my carryon luggage?" Sept. 3, 2010. (Sept. 22, 2010)http://blog.tsa.gov/2010/09/gel-aerosol-and-stick-deodorant-which.html